Showing posts with label USA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label USA. Show all posts

Monday, January 27, 2025

The right answers to Trump 3 – Panama

 

 

Panama

Trump wants the Panama Canal back. It is a relatively new original idea, compared to Canada and Greenland, and the wildest and most imperialist idea. Should France and Britain follow and reclaim the Suez Canal, which Nasser nationalised in 1956? Of course, the security of strategic sea routes is in everyone's fundamental interest and right. In this respect, the Panama Canal is one of the most important, compared only with the importance of the Suez Canal. But beyond that, there are also a good number of very important and critical places, routes, straits in the Arabian Gulf, in the Red Sea. Their security in all respects (military, economic and logistical security) is of fundamental interest to all. But there can be no solution to the problem of America asking for the return of the gift that Jimmy Carter generously gave Panama in 1977. For Panama's solidarity is as valuable and deserves the same recognition and respect as America's, or anyone else's, solidarity.

Whether the Chinese have too big a role in the management and control of the Panama Canal is a complex issue. Indeed, China is now Panama's second largest partner after the United States. But the Canal is important to China not only because of Sino-Panamanian relations, but also because China is one of the largest carriers of goods by sea, it sheds its goods all over the world, and the security of the sea routes is of the utmost importance to them. But that does not mean they have the right to get their hands on the Panama Canal. But that is not the case, from what we know. They are very actively involved in the maintenance and development of the canal, but for them, maritime shipping in general, and port construction in particular are strategic sectors. They are very active in this area, and you can't begrudge them that. China had a very generous plan to build a second canal in Nicaragua. This took shape and started in the early '10s, and then it turned out to be too big, too difficult, too expensive and quietly almost died out, but you never know... Technology is improving, it could well be that in a few years it would not be so difficult and so expensive to build this temporary canal in Nicaragua. But that is another question. The previous question here is what to do about the safety of the priority shipping routes.

         It's quite obvious that the solution is not for America to ensure their security, perhaps by occupying them or by placing them under its jurisdiction. The solution that is offered, I think, is quite obvious and logical, to organise an international force under the auspices of the United Nations to look after the security of the important sea routes, all over the globe. This would be a new, very important, very significant and very strategic direction and function in the hands of the international organisation. We should think very seriously about organising the implementation of this. This cannot be the solution that NATO has practically used and is using against the Houthis in the Red Sea. It cannot be a unilateral, particularistic force; it should be a legitimate, international force in which everyone could and should participate, under a common, unified command.

This is a very serious initiative, again, and again I have to say, for the third time, thank you, Mr. Trump, for dropping the ball, now the world has to strike.

 



* * *


The right answers to Trump 2 – Canada

 

 

Canada

The United States and Canada are two former British colonies with very similar fates. The United States came into being first, through a fierce and prolonged War of Independence (1775-1783). Even then, many revolutionaries, including Benjamin Franklin, hoped that the British colonies in the north would revolt and that a new independent state would be created across the northern continent. This did not happen. The Canadian colonies, although there were later minor and major movements, remained loyal to the British crown until the 'end'.

So they did indeed go their separate ways, and these separate ways still run side by side today. But the idea of togetherness has persisted throughout, particularly in American thought, in American political life. It has also been embraced by several very strong ideological currents, such as the Destiny manifesto.

Well, there are many ways to approach the question of whether it is realistic, legitimate, beneficial for Canada to join the United States. But why not? They are indeed two brother nations, however vague the concept may be. Not to mention the fact that both societies share a common Indian base, again akin to a kinship, and a strong multi-ethnic stratum.

With a bit of topical political malice, one could say that Americans and Canadians are as much real brothers as Russians and Ukrainians. And how interesting that Canada and Ukraine have something in common in name. The word Ukrainian means "end-region". And Canada comes from the word “Kanata”, which means village, "upper end".

There is no doubt that in recent decades a distinct Canadian identity has begun to emerge, and it is legitimate to speak of Canadian nationalism. It may come as a surprise, but in the 19th century (1812-1815) a full-scale war (6,765 dead and wounded) broke out between the USA and Canada (then a British colony). Since then, both countries have called the US-Canada border the 'frontier of peace', which was for a long time freely crossable and mostly still is, much to Trump's chagrin. Not to mention that a free trade agreement (NAFTA) between the two countries (of which Mexico is part) has been in force since 1992.

Regardless of the history, the reality is that a US-Canada merger would be historic. Many people, for various reasons, are afraid and reluctant. Some because they believe it would strengthen Trump and the Trump-ruled USA. One fears the liberal bastion that Canada has become under Trudeau's government.

Would it be good for the US and Canada to unite? This question should of course be answered by the Americans and Canadians first, but no one should be forbidden to have an opinion on this. And there is not only private opinion, there is public opinion that speaks in the name of the world and is formed also in the name of the world.

For such world public opinion would presumably be clearly positive, as it would work in the direction of integration. It has to be admitted, that - whether it is true or not - this issue will be on the agenda and will come up sooner or later. There are several reasons to believe that it will start very soon, in a meaningful way. But however much there is agreement and serious the intentions, it is certain that this will be a very long process. There are legal systems, administrative systems, a thousand things to be reconciled. So there is a lot of work to be done by both sides. Some processes can perhaps be completed in a couple of years, but overall, for two such large countries, it may take decades.

But this does not change the point. So, presumably, a serious integration will start and take place here anyway. I think that is the most important thing, and it is a very encouraging, positive development for the world. It is an old recognition that the vast majority of people are very frightened and terrified by the idea of world government. But common sense tells us that humanity, which is one race, one family, one unit – we are all in the same boat in the cosmos – needs a common, democratic, effective, good world government for its very existence.

World governance. Knowing and acknowledging the current situation, this will probably take many decades, if not centuries, but the smallest step in this direction is of enormous importance, and the unification of the United States and Canada could be a very positive example. One would hope that this would not remain an isolated, isolated example, but would inspire many others to follow. It would not be a bad thing at all to 'fashion' merger wherever possible.

Among them there may be some that are not so good, so democratic, so clever, but that is history. We must leave room for it. I think there are plenty of integration possibilities. But we have to admit that integration is not a simple thing. In Europe we have been struggling for fifty years with the integration, and we are nowhere. It is certainly a difficult, controversial process, so it would be worthwhile to do integration where it is easy. Even within Europe. We should not wait for these 30 or so, now counting the new members we are expecting, the Western Balkans and others, to become 30-35-40 members. We should not wait for this multitude to agree on a great integration. It is more realistic to have individual small integrations within the current framework. One of the most daring examples is the legitimate, historically based unification of Germany and Austria. It is not wise to reject this just on basis of bad memories connected to the l938 Anschluss. Germany and Austria are really two brother countries. Although the Austrians have a distinct Austrian identity, they speak the same language and have almost the same state model and provincial structure. Otherwise, Austrians can retain their Austrian identity, just as the Bavarians have retained their Bavarian identity. And why not, Luxembourg could also join the unitary federal republic.

It's not important to give everyone a prescription, but it's quite clear that there are opportunities for integration everywhere, on every continent. In Asia and Indochina, so Laos, Vietnam, Cambodia. These are also three brother countries, which have been very closely united over many periods, and are still cooperating very closely in many respects, economically, culturally, politically, militarily. It is also possible in the Middle East, in the Arab world, in Africa in various ways, probably a gradual unification starting from South Africa, with the Southern African confederation occupying the whole of South Africa, south of the equator. It could also integrate the Central American countries separately under the US, in the same way the Spanish-speaking South American countries could be integrated. Thus, gradually, slowly and of course with easy, relatively easy integrations, a new world order and a new world balance could emerge. So let me say that now the merger of Canada and the Americas could give a big boost to this process. So that we can say a big thank you to Trump for taking this first step. Good luck to him.

 



 * * *